LOOOOOOVE my pigeon hoodie! However, if I could leave a 4.5 star review I would, only because it says to size down but you 100% shouldn't. I am 5'8" and I usually wear a 2XL-3XL in most shirts jackets etc. I was between sizes and I played it safe going a size up to 3XL but after receiving it I think I would have been even happier going up to a 4XL. I still love it, I've gotten so many compliments already! The inside is like a soft blanket and the jacket has some weight to it so I feel SOOOO cozy and warm wearing it. I also love the thumb holes, however I feel like the thumb holes are too small for my thumbs, so I did have to stretch that part out a bit. I also would have made it a bit longer, but I imagine that goes hand in hand with ordering a larger size. I personally would order two sizes up from what your measurements say or whatever you normally wear. Overall I am very very happy with it and I'm happy it matches my pigeon wallet. I'm excited for my crow one to arrive too :-)